CALL NOW  (302) 658-1717

In summary judgment opinion in Roberts v. DP&L, Superior Court Judge Robert B. Young eviserates Delaware Wrongful Death Statute

In a summary judgment opinion in the case of Roberts v. DP&L, et. al., released on January 30, 2009, The Honorable Robert B. Young, a judge of the Delaware Superior Court, sitting in Kent County, applied common law negligence principles to the statutorily created Delaware Wrongful Death statute in holding that in order for a beneficiary to recover for pain and suffering for the death of a loved one, the beneficiary must show physical injury. This ruling causes a conflict in Delaware Superior Court opinions and effectively eviscerates the Delaware Wrongful Death statute.

To reach this ruling the court framed the issue thusly:

“The question remains as to whether the general common law regarding the necessity to show physical injury to recover for mental anguish in a tort claim is somehow, altered or abated or diminished when the claim arises out of a statutory wrongful death claim.”

The court, relied on the Delaware Supreme Court case of Merganthaler v. Asbestos Corp. of America, 480 A.2d 647 (Del. 1984) which held “that any claim in mental anguish requires physical injury”, and ruled that Plaintiffs had not presented any evidence of physical injury, required by Merganthaler, to recover for mental anguish or emotional distress.

In order to reach this ruling the Court had to hold contrary to the 1985 Delaware Superior Court opinion of Okie v. Owens, 1985 WL 189292 (Del. Super.).

Rated for
The National Top 100 Trial Lawyers

CALL 302-658-1717

    *Free consultation for Delaware personal injury or auto injury cases. No attorney-client relationship is created by use of this contact form. Read disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

    Auto Law Articles


    “I was in for the fight of my life, against a large company. By myself, I didn’t have chance, but having E. Martin Knepper…I was able to persevere.”
    -Kay O.

    “Exceeded my expectations!”

    See more reviews.

    Attorney Ratings

    E. Martin Knepper Avvo Rated

    Knepper Stratton National Trial Lawyers Top 100

    Knepper Stratton Top 10 Trucking Trial Lawyers 2018 Truck Accident Attorney Academy Knepper Stratton 2018 2019

     Delaware Trial Lawyers Barbara Stratton