CALL NOW  (302) 658-1717

Delaware Superior Court dismisses two out of Plaintiffs’ three Lemon Law claims for faulty tire pressure sensor

In an October 1, 2008 opinion in the case of Mayew v. Chrysler, LLC, the Honorable Peggy Ableman dismissed Plaintiff’s “lemon law” claims brought pursuant to Delaware’s Lemon Law and Delaware’s Consumer Fraud Act for failure, “as a matter of law…to establish a substantial impairment to the value, safety, or use of their Jeep, nor can they demonstrate any fraud, misrepresentation or concealment.” The court allowed plaintiffs to proceed on their claim pursuant to the Magnuson-Moss Federal Warranty Improvement Act.

The court disallowed Plaintiffs’ ASE master certified repair technician expert opinions on diminution of value to Plaintiffs’ Jeep as a result of the alleged defect and causation of the alleged defect because the expert’s, “opinion was not based on reliable methods.” The court cited to Delaware Rule of Evidence 702 and Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., in support of it’s opinion.

The court found that the defect alleged by Plaintiffs’, a malfunctioning tire air pressure warning light, did not “substantially impair the car’s value as Plaintiffs were still able to drive it a significant distance in the year they owned it.”

Rated for
The National Top 100 Trial Lawyers

CALL 302-658-1717

    *Free consultation for Delaware personal injury or auto injury cases. No attorney-client relationship is created by use of this contact form. Read disclaimer at the bottom of this page.

    Auto Law Articles


    “I was in for the fight of my life, against a large company. By myself, I didn’t have chance, but having E. Martin Knepper…I was able to persevere.”
    -Kay O.

    “Exceeded my expectations!”

    See more reviews.

    Attorney Ratings

    E. Martin Knepper Avvo Rated

    Knepper Stratton National Trial Lawyers Top 100

    Knepper Stratton Top 10 Trucking Trial Lawyers 2018 Truck Accident Attorney Academy Knepper Stratton 2018 2019

     Delaware Trial Lawyers Barbara Stratton